Contact Us
206-801-1188
425-641-8010

Toll Free
877-50-INJURY
(877-504-6587)

Free Confidential
Personal Injury Case Evaluation



Eller Law Firm on Facebook

The Public Duty Doctrine and Legislative Intent

The public duty doctrine is a defense to claims against state and local governmental entities.  The doctrine in its simplest terms is express by the observation that a “duty to all is a duty to no one”.[1]

The legislative intent exception applies where the terms of a statute evidence a clear intent to identify and protect a particular and circumscribed class of persons.[2] The statutory language must clearly express this intent; a court will not imply it.[3] Where the legislative intent exception applies, a member of the identified class may bring a tort action against the governmental entity for its violation of the statute.[4]

Washington courts have held that statutes and regulations establishing a campus police force and requiring first-year college students to live in student housing was not intended to identify and protect an injured party as a member of the Washington State University student body[5] that the state securities act was not intended to protect individual investors but only the investing public;[6] that the state building code act was intended to protect the general public, not the specific class of building occupants;[7] that statutes and regulations enacted to prevent the spread of brucellosis, a disease of cattle, were intended to protect the general public, not the specific class of dairy operators.[8]

Other exceptions to the public duty doctrine include

failure to enforce

the rescue doctrine, and

a special relationship.

This general information is not a substitute for legal advice.  For advice about your circumstances consult a personal injury attorney.


[1] Meaney v. Dodd, 111 Wn.2d 174, 178, 759 P.2d 455 (1988).

[2] Hannum v. Washington State Dep’t of Licensing, 181 P.3d 915, 144 Wash.App. 354 (2008), citing Ravenscroft v. Wash. Water Power Co., 136 Wn.2d 911, 929, 969 P.2d 75 (1998).

[3] Ravenscroft, 136 Wn.2d at 930.

[4] Ravenscroft, 136 Wn.2d at 929.

[5] Johnson v. State, 77 Wn. App. 934, 938, 894 P.2d 1366 (1995).

[6] Baerlein v. State, 92 Wn.2d 229, 232, 595 P.2d 930 (1979).

[7] Taylor v. Stevens County, 111 Wn.2d 159, 166, 759 P.2d 447 (1988).

[8] Honcoop v. State, 111 Wn.2d 182, 188, 759 P.2d 1188 (1988).

Post a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Personal Injury Attorney
Injury Case Evaluation
Free personal injury attorney case evaluation.
  • Court of Appeals Rules in Public Duty Doctrine Case
     Our law firm was not involved in the lawsuit described in this article. The Washington Court of Appeals recently ruled that application of the public duty doctrine negated a claim against a fire district for the destruction of a partially constructed house and other property.[1] The same analysis applies to personal injury claims.  The plaintiffs lost […]
  • Washington Courts Rule on Landlord Liability for Dog Bite Injury
     Our law firm was not involved in the personal injury lawsuit described in this article. A recent Washington Court of Appeals decision considered arguments for landlord liability for dog bite injury.  The plaintiff was injured in a common areas by a dog owned by another tenant. The plaintiff claimed that the dog had attacked other […]
  • Court Dismisses Case for Improper Service of Summons and Complaint
    Our law firm was not involved in the personal injury lawsuit described in this article. In a recent decision the Washington Court of Appeals considered an issue of service of a summons and complaint. [1] Proper service of the summons and complaint is a prerequisite to the court obtaining jurisdiction over a party, and a […]
  • Medical Malpractice Statute Notice Requirements Declared Unconstitutional
    Our law firm was not involved in the personal injury lawsuit described in this article. Washington medical malpractice statutes had required an injury claimant to both obtain a certificate of merit from an expert before filing suit and to give 90 days notice to a health care provider before filing suit. Last year the Washington […]
  • Landowner Duty to Police in Washington
    Our law firm was not involved in the personal injury lawsuit described in this article. In a recent premises liability case Division One of the Washington Court of Appeals considered what duty, if any, a landowner owes to a police officer.[1] On the night of December 20, 2005, a King County Sheriff’s Department Deputy entered […]
  • Woman Claiming Injury Unsuccessfully Argues Appeal Without an Attorney
    Our law firm was not involved in the personal injury lawsuit described in this article. A woman who fell and was in injured appealed the trial court results. She unsuccessfully argued her appeal without the assistance of an attorney. She injured her ankle when she slipped on a substance on the floor in a Safeway […]
  • Person Who Fell on Wet Floor Sign Wins Appeal
    Our law firm was not involved in the personal injury lawsuit described in this article. A customer slipped and fell on a fallen wet floor sign. The trial court dismissed the case on Petsmart’s motion for summary judgment. The Washington Court of Appeals reversed. The customer several minutes browsing the dog toy aisle. He caught […]
  • Auto Accident Injury Victim’s Default Judgment Set Aside
    Our law firm was not involved in the personal injury lawsuit described in this article. A woman injured in a motor vehicle accident served the Washington Secretary of State because she was unable to locate the other driver to effect personal service.  The trial court entered a default judgment.  The court awarded $12,000 in general […]
    Personal Injury Attorney serving entire Puget Sound

  • King County including Seattle, Kent, Auburn, Renton, Federal Way, Bellevue, Bothell
  • Pierce County including Tacoma, Puyallup, Lakewood
  • Snohomish County including Everett, Lynnwood, Edmonds, Marysville

Lawyers blogs Resources Medical Malpractice Legal Resources - Regional information on medical personal injury resources.